A search warrant for a wanted suspect resulted in the arrest of four people.
The LaGrange County Sheriff’s Department said in a release they were were notified just before 1 p.m. last Thursday that a Wanted Person, Jeremy W. Tuttle, was at a Hudson residence (11990 E 600 S, Lot 6 Hudson, IN).
Investigative reports indicate that earlier that morning, Tuttle, who is from Stroh, had been seen at the residence and had not been observed leaving the location. Deputies made several attempts to get someone to answer the door, but had no response.
Police then applied for a search warrant of the home, which was granted by a judge.
Further investigation revealed that the homeowner, Mary Dolch, was inside the residence. Also inside was Nathan Ray Harter and Morgan Paige Cusick.
Deputies searched the residence for Tuttle and found a hidden compartment that was concealed in a bedroom of the home. Tuttle was apprehended under the trailer and taken into custody.
Authorities had been looking for Tuttle since last Tuesday after police allege he took them on a small chase. The pursuit began when an officer was attempting to make a traffic stop, at which time Tuttle was the suspected driver of a stolen vehicle last week from Hudson. The vehicle was later found unoccupied, but evidence pointed authorities to Tuttle.
Tuttle was arrested and booked into the LaGrange County Jail for preliminary charges Warrant for Failure to appear (DeKalb County), Resisting Law Enforcement, Theft of an automobile, and Resisting Law Enforcement by fleeing in a motor vehicle.
Mary Dolch, Nathan Harter, and Morgan Cusick were arrested and booked into the LaGrange County Jail for preliminary charges of aiding a criminal and obstruction of Justice.
Additional charges are anticipated for several of the individuals as the matter is still under investigation.
(Pictured below: Jeremy W Tuttle, Mary E Dolch, Morgan P Cusick, & Nathan R Harter)
(09-12-2025) Woman Arrested In Garrett For Firing Gun
(09-10-2025) Elmet Technologies Secures $5.1 Million Strategic Order
(09-10-2025) Carra And Lindsey Holding In District Office Hours Friday
(09-09-2025) Randy Miller Issues Apology
(09-08-2025) Sturgis Man Charged With Multiple CSC Counts In Branch County
(09-08-2025) Braun Names ISP Superintendent New Secretary Of Public Safety
(09-08-2025) Driver Hurt When Dump Truck Rolls Over
(09-06-2025) Sex Offender Investigation Leads To Discovery Of Child Porn
(09-06-2025) Randy Miller Resigns As Westview Superintendent
(09-05-2025) Consumers Energy Says Beware Of Scam
(09-05-2025) Auburn Woman Killed In Crash In Alaska
(09-05-2025) Special Prosecutor Requested For Miller Case
(09-05-2025) Grand Jury Indicts Elkhart County Clerk And Chief Deputy Clerk
(09-05-2025) LaGrange Co. Commission Approves Highway Engineer’s Requests
(09-05-2025) Angola To Do Fall Fire Hydrant Flushing
(09-03-2025) St. Joseph County Man Wins $2 Million In Instant Game
(09-03-2025) Police Identify Victims In Fatal Elkhart County Crash
(09-03-2025) Two Kendallville Men Involved In Two Vehicle Crash
(09-03-2025) Westview Superintendent On Administrative Leave
(09-02-2025) Westview Superintendent Arrested On OWI Charges